Our top picks · Auto insurance

Cheapest car insurance companies of 2026

Our editors compare average rates, coverage options and customer experience to find insurers that offer real value, not just a low sticker price.

Advertiser disclosure: RateWisdom is compensated by some of the providers that appear on this page, which may affect where and in what order they appear. Our editorial picks are not influenced by compensation. Learn more.

Our picks at a glance

Editorial content needed: add the ranked providers, data points and “best for” labels from editorial research and partner agreements. The rows below are placeholders.
InsurerBest forAvg. full coverage (yearly)Avg. minimum coverage (yearly)Offer
[PROVIDER 1][DATA][DATA][DATA]Get a quote
[PROVIDER 2][DATA][DATA][DATA]Get a quote
[PROVIDER 3][DATA][DATA][DATA]Get a quote
[PROVIDER 4][DATA][DATA][DATA]Get a quote
[PROVIDER 5][DATA][DATA][DATA]Get a quote
[PROVIDER 6][DATA][DATA][DATA]Get a quote

The cheapest insurer for you depends on you

Rates vary widely by driver, car and ZIP code. Compare personalized quotes in minutes.

Compare auto quotes

How we choose

Editorial content needed: confirm and describe the actual methodology (data sources, rate sample profiles, weighting of price vs. service, how often the list is updated).

We look at average rates for sample driver profiles, the coverage and discounts each insurer offers, and signals of customer experience such as complaint data and claims satisfaction. Price matters most on this list, but an insurer has to be a solid choice overall to make it.

Why your price may be different

Insurers weigh factors like your driving record, location, vehicle, age and credit-based insurance score (where allowed) differently. The insurer that’s cheapest on average may not be cheapest for you, so comparing quotes is the best way to find your price.

Ways to pay less

Ask about every discount

Safe driver, multi-policy, good student, paid-in-full and telematics programs can all lower your premium.

Right-size your coverage

Dropping collision on an older car or raising your deductible can save money. Here’s how to decide.

Related guides